Curriculum Access System
for Elementary Science
http://cases-soe.web.itd.umich.edu/
(a unit)
Author:
Modified by:
unit overview
table of contents
unit calendar
worksheets
Note that these worksheets are not automatically included in this packet. To
retreive and print them, click on each of these links.
summary of materials needed for this unit
driving question
What is a driving question?
This unit addresses the following subquestions:
Why are these good questions?
What is a driving question?
A driving question is a question that is elaborated, explored, and answered by the students and the teacher. The driving question encourages students to link together different topic areas and apply knowledge in real-world settings. To use a driving question, you could:
- Post the driving question prominently in the classroom (for example, on the bulletin board) and refer to it often.
- Have students periodically write entries in their science journals explaining the activity they are doing and how it helps them answer the driving question.
standards
This unit is aligned with
science background
This page compiles discussions of the science content covered in this unit. See the content section in each lesson plan for more specific science content. Note that the explanations provided here are typically in more depth than the level of understanding you would expect from your students.
students' alternative ideas
What are alternative ideas?
What are alternative ideas?
- They are scientifically inaccurate ideas that students hold. Some people call them misconceptions.
- They are based on previous experiences students have had.
Why is it important to know the alternative ideas my students hold?
- Students often hold alternative ideas about science topics (also called misconceptions). These ideas are based on previous experiences they have had with the topic.
- Students tend to hold on very tightly to these ideas. In turn, these ideas greatly influence their learning.
- If alternative ideas are not addressed through instruction, they tend to remain.
How do I obtain information on the alternative ideas my students hold?
Asking questions and listening carefully to students' responses is key to learning about their ideas. Some guidelines for doing this include:
- Try not to indicate which answers are correct and which are not. Students are very good at picking up on these cues.
- Provide a balance between open and closed questions.
- Let students talk as much as possible.
- Allow enough time for students to formulate their answers.
- Follow up unclear answers with probing questions like, Can you tell me more about that? Can you give an example of what you mean? Why do you think that is the case?
- You can also find a summary of potential alternative ideas at:
http://www.project2061.org/tools/benchol/bolframe.htm .
inquiry adaptatons
What is inquiry in CASES?
- Inquiry involves engaging students in scientifically oriented questions, gathering evidence, producing explanations based on that evidence, and communicating their findings.
- Inquiry encourages students to work and think like scientists.
- Gathering evidence is necessary to draw conclusions. Students often think that any opinion is as valid as any other opinion. In science, however, opinions are judged by how strongly they are supported by evidence. Communicating findings and justifying conclusions are two essential aspects of this process.
What are the benefits of doing inquiry? In addition to helping students better understand the process of investigating the question, engaging in inquiry-oriented activities helps students better understand the topic they are investigating (content) and develop, carry-out, and evaluate investigations that are best suited to their question (problem-solving).
What is a driving question?
It is an overarching topic that helps organize activities and investigations in a project-based science classroom. It encourages students to see connections between various learning activities and apply their knowledge to the real world.
When should students develop the questions? When should the teacher develop the questions?
Both teachers and students can pose questions in science class. It might be easier to decide on these questions as you plan. Within the unit however, both teachers and students can create questions to answer, depending on time considerations, available resources, and students� comfort level with inquiry.
What makes a good representation?
Representations should be (scientifically) accurate and appropriate, understandable, helpful for promoting learning, and reasonable given your instructional context.
What makes a good representation?
Representations should be (scientifically) accurate and appropriate, understandable, helpful for promoting learning, and reasonable given your instructional context.
What makes a good representation?
Representations should be (scientifically) accurate and appropriate, understandable, helpful for promoting learning, and reasonable given your instructional context.
What makes a good representation?
Representations should be (scientifically) accurate and appropriate, understandable, helpful for promoting learning, and reasonable given your instructional context.
What makes a good representation?
Representations should be (scientifically) accurate and appropriate, understandable, helpful for promoting learning, and reasonable given your instructional context.
What makes a good representation?
Representations should be (scientifically) accurate and appropriate, understandable, helpful for promoting learning, and reasonable given your instructional context.
The tables below will give you ideas about how to change the lesson plans in this unit to meet your students' needs.
Questioning & predicting
If the lesson focuses on questioning & predicting and if your students have:
|
more experience with engaging in questions, you might consider...
|
less experience with engaging in questions, you might consider...
|
| Encouraging small groups of students to ask and answer their own questions |
Having the whole class answer the same questions |
| Letting student-generated questions drive the investigations within the unit (you might guide them by making a shorter list from their questions) |
Letting students investigate answers to questions you provide for them |
| Remember: Giving kids ownership over questions will make their investigations meaningful. |
Remember: It's important that students are engaged with questions -- even if you're the one asking them |
Explanations & evidence
If the lesson focuses on explanations & evidence and if your students have:
|
more experience with explaining their results, you might consider...
|
less experience with explaining their results, you might consider...
|
| Encouraging students to use the word "evidence" as they explain their findings and making sure they actually do use evidence |
Spending as much class time as is needed to explain to students what "evidence" means - talk about what would and wouldn't count as evidence |
Allowing groups or individuals to come up with their own explanations using evidence
|
Modeling the process of using evidence to explain a result. Use "I think....because..." templates to help students organize their thoughts. Do these as a class for the first few investigations.
|
| Making sure students focus on showing "why" something happened, not just "how" or "that" it happened |
Making sure students focus on showing "why" something happened, not just "how" or "that" it happened |
Communicating & justifying
If the lesson focuses on communicating & justifying and if your students have:
|
more experience with communicating and justifying their findings, you might consider...
|
less experience with communicating and justifying their findings, you might consider...
|
| Encouraging students to design their own method of communicating and/or choose their audience |
Having the entire class present findings using same procedure. |
| Allowing students to form their own argument |
Providing guidelines to help students communicate their argument. |
| Encouraging students to question each other on their findings so students will justify their conclusions to each other |
Encouraging students to justify their findings by asking them "How do you know?" while guiding them in learning how to rely on evidence. |